Tuesday, April 24, 2018

“Ozymandias”: A Poem in Motion – Part 1


For many readers, Ozymandias stands at the heart of Percy Bysshe Shelley's eponymous poem. Indeed, this once-great king does command a certain pride of place, but to focus only on him is to risk missing another of the poem's key features: motion. In this essay, I will examine three patterns of motion in “Ozymandias,” voice, time, and space, before reflecting on how a close reading of the poem's motion might actually shift its center.
Ozymandias” presents a series of voices in motion. The poem begins in the first person with the narrator's “I.” This “I,” however, performs only one act, meeting “a traveller” (line 1), and this action is fairly passive. The narrator does not seek or question the traveller; he just meets him, perhaps through a chance encounter. We learn no more about the narrator “I” or his actions before he fades into the background and becomes part of the listening audience.

The voice then shifts to the “traveller from an antique land” (line 1). We know very little else about him, and even this phrase does not tell us much. Is he “from” an antique land in the sense that he is a native of a foreign country, or has he merely traveled to some distant place and come back? We cannot tell, but unlike the narrator, the traveller has something to say, and his speech comprises the remainder of the poem, nearly thirteen lines. He describes a scene he has encountered in his travels, a “colossal” yet broken and decayed statue (line 13), once great but now only “lifeless” pieces of stone lying in a desert (lines 7, 3).

In the midst of the traveller's account, however, the poem's voice changes again. There are words inscribed on the pedestal of this crumbled monolith, and in them we hear a third voice, ringing out through time, the voice of an ancient king: “My name is Ozymandias, King of Kings; / Look on my Works, ye Mighty, and despair!” (lines 11-12). These are powerful words. A first person declarative statement names the man who desires to speak for all eternity. A superlative proclaims him to be the ruler of all kings. An imperative offers a challenge to look upon his Works (note the emphatic capital), but this challenge does not apply to everyone, only the Mighty, compared to whom he is even more powerful. Then these Mighty (again note the capital; these people are great indeed) must despair, for they shall never prove a match for Ozymandias.

Is this a threat? Is Ozymandias planning to conquer them all? We do not know, but his is a domineering voice, a sneering voice to match his statue's “sneer of cold command” (line 5). Suddenly, however, the king's voice fades, and we hear the traveller once again as he completes his description and the poem ends. We do not return to the narrator.

Tuesday, April 17, 2018

Eucatastrophe in Harry Potter, Part 8

We've discovered plenty of eucatastrophes in the Harry Potter series. Every book exhibits at least one, if not several, of the sudden, joyous turns that lead to a happy ending and leave readers almost breathless with delight at their beauty. We've been stunned and amazed, charmed and elated as darkness becomes light, near despair becomes unlooked for fulfillment, and the hardest roads leads to the greatest happiness. 

We're left asking ourselves, perhaps, what all these Harry Potter eucatastrophes have in common. Dumbledore would know the answer: love. Love protects Harry, ensuring that Quirrell cannot hold him. Love calls Fawkes to Harry in the Chamber of Secrets. Love sends Harry's Patronus across the lake. Love keeps Harry holding his wand steady in the golden cage of Priori Incantatem. Love expels Voldemort from Harry's body in the Ministry of Magic. Love encourages Harry to keep on seeking Horcruxes even when he might easily have given up. Love leads Harry to shout “Expelliarmus!” one last time to finally defeat Voldemort. 

Indeed, the eucatastrophes of Harry Potter are powered by love, the kind of love that wills the very best for another person and then does everything possible to help that person attain it, the love that chooses to give everything, even one's life, that others may live safely and happily, the love that sustains a person in the darkest of times, the love that Harry Potter has in such great abundance.

Monday, April 9, 2018

Eucatastrope in Harry Potter, Part 7


Oh the eucatastrophes in Harry Potter and the Deathly Hallows! For all its darkness and terror and pain, the novel is punctuated throughout by eucatastrophes that serve as high notes, reminders of hope, love, and peace, expressions of what Harry and his friends are fighting for.

Let's list a few of the eucatastrophes, those sudden, joyous turns that give us readers a strong sense of delight and hope for a happy ending.

* Dudley Dursley's goodbye to Harry – No, it's not that dramatic, but who would have expected Dudley to awkwardly admit what Harry had done for him and to shake his cousin's hand? Maybe he turns out all right after all!

* Kingsley's Patronous warning the Weasleys and their guests just in time to avoid disaster at Bill and Fleur's wedding

* Kreacher's sudden change of behavior after Harry gives him Regulus' locket – Who would have expected that Kreacher could cook delicious meals!?!

* The Silver Doe Patronous that leads Harry, seemingly miraculously, to the Sword of Gryffindor

* Hermione's voice unexpectedly issuing from the Deluminator to let Ron know his friends' location

* Dobby's surprising appearance at Malfoy Manor – Dobby, the free elf, returns to the place of his enslavement to save his friends and gives his life in the process.

* Harry, Ron, and Hermione's flight out of Gringotts on a dragon

* Harry not dying when he is hit by Voldemort's Killing Curse – In fact, he gets a chance to speak with Dumbledore in “King's Cross” and makes the decision to return to fight to the finish.

* Neville pulling Gryffindor's Sword out of the Sorting Hat

* Harry's final “Expelliarmus!” – Voldemort's Killing Curse rebounds and hits the Dark Lord himself. Harry catches the Elder Wand. The reign of terror is finally over thanks to one last eucatastrophe.

Tuesday, April 3, 2018

Eucatastrophe in Harry Potter, Part 6


Harry Potter and the Half-Blood Prince ends on an especially dark note. The Death Eaters have entered Hogwarts. Dumbledore is dead. Voldemort seems sure to regain power now that his greatest rival is out of the way. The Wizarding World looks to the future with dread and almost despair.

There seems to be no eucatastrophe in sight. No one suddenly stops the Death Eaters from invading Hogwarts. No one miraculously steps up to prevent Dumbledore's death. There is no joyous turn this time, no happy ending.

Or is there?

Perhaps the eucatastrophe of this sixth installment of the Harry Potter series isn't especially noticeable because it happens within Harry. In the past, Harry has not always handled tragedy well. His response to Sirius' death, for instance, was a cross between searing anger and near despair.

But this time, Harry, quite unexpectedly, reacts differently. After Dumbledore's funeral, Ron, Hermione, and Harry are discussing whether or not Hogwarts will remain open. Harry says simply, “I'm not coming back even if it does reopen.” He goes on to explain that he plans “to track down the rest of the Horcruxes,” just as Dumbledore would want him to do. “I've got to find them and destroy them, and then I've got to go after the seventh bit of Voldemort's soul, the bit that's still in his body, and I'm the one who's going to kill him,” Harry continues. He speaks calmly and resolutely. He has made his decision, and he will carry out his plan even if it costs him everything, including his life.

What a change! This is a very different Harry from the one who railed at Dumbledore after Sirius' death. He has learned much, and he is ready to tread the path he knows he must take.

This may not be a typical eucatastrophe, but it is amazing and beautiful in its own way, and it may even give readers an unexpected pleasure and joy to see Harry face the apparently hopeless state of the Wizarding World and vow to rise above it with dignity and courage.